Complete drafted population
11 quarterbacks
All seven rounds, with no minimum starts required to enter the audit. Undrafted signings are a separate population.
Every drafted QB. The same rules.
All 11 quarterbacks drafted in 2012, independently checked against the published Tier 1–3 achievement rules through the 2025 NFL season and its postseason.
New: achievement results for all 407 modern archive entries →
Complete drafted population
All seven rounds, with no minimum starts required to enter the audit. Undrafted signings are a separate population.
Achievement results
Wilson meets Tier 3. No player meets Tier 1 or 2. A rules result does not label a career a failure.
Opportunity verified
3 at or above 100; 8 below. Griffin’s retirement status at the cutoff remains unresolved; it cannot change his achievement result.
Regular-season starts exclude playoff starts. Achievement counts include the postseason belonging to the 2025 season, even when games took place in early 2026. Reviewed November 16, 2026.
| Quarterback | Round · overall | NFL starts | Achievement result | Eligibility | Mike’s existing cohort |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andrew Luck | 1 · 1 | 86 | Below Tier 1–3 thresholds | Luck exception | Tier 4 · eye test |
| Robert Griffin III | 1 · 2 | 42 | Below Tier 1–3 thresholds | Cutoff status unresolved | Outside selected group |
| Ryan Tannehill | 1 · 8 | 151 | Below Tier 1–3 thresholds | 100-start floor met | Outside selected group |
| Brandon Weeden | 1 · 22 | 25 | Below Tier 1–3 thresholds | Retired; below 100 starts | Outside selected group |
| Brock Osweiler | 2 · 57 | 30 | Below Tier 1–3 thresholds | Retired; below 100 starts | Outside selected group |
| Russell Wilson | 3 · 75 | 202* | Tier 3 | 100-start floor met | Tier 3 |
| Nick Foles | 3 · 88 | 58 | Below Tier 1–3 thresholds | Retired; below 100 starts | Outside selected group |
| Kirk Cousins | 4 · 102 | 167 | Below Tier 1–3 thresholds | 100-start floor met | Tier 4 · eye test |
| Ryan Lindley | 6 · 185 | 6 | Below Tier 1–3 thresholds | Retired; below 100 starts | Outside selected group |
| B.J. Coleman | 7 · 243 | 0* | Below Tier 1–3 thresholds | Retired; below 100 starts | Outside selected group |
| Chandler Harnish | 7 · 253 | 0 | Below Tier 1–3 thresholds | Retired; below 100 starts | Outside selected group |
* Reconstructed from affirmative evidence. Wilson: 199 starts through 2024 plus 3 in 2025. Coleman: practice-squad-only 2012 season and subsequent career evidence establish zero NFL regular-season starts; a blank table was not treated as zero.
His 2019 AP Second-Team All-Pro selection and two Super Bowl starts independently meet Tier 3 routes. Neither a single Super Bowl win nor his conference-title starts elevate him to Tier 2 under these rules.
Foles was a Super Bowl-winning starter and Super Bowl MVP. Luck and Cousins remain Mike’s editorial Tier 4 choices. These distinct achievements and opinions are preserved; nonmembership is not a failed career.
Published Luck exception; retirement confirmed, 86 regular-season starts.
The complete qualifying finish sets were audited. This is not a claim of zero MVP votes; lower-ranked ballots were not exhaustively collected.
conference Championship Starts: 2014 · Source 1
Cutoff status evidence: Source 1
Below 100 starts. A primary retirement announcement dated at/before the 2025 cutoff was not established. Inactivity, a later retired-player registry, and a blank career table are not a dated announcement.
The complete qualifying finish sets were audited. This is not a claim of zero MVP votes; lower-ranked ballots were not exhaustively collected.
At least 100 regular-season starts; retirement status cannot change eligibility.
The complete qualifying finish sets were audited. This is not a claim of zero MVP votes; lower-ranked ballots were not exhaustively collected.
conference Championship Starts: 2019 · Source 1
Cutoff status evidence: Source 1
Verified retired before cutoff and below ordinary 100-start threshold.
The complete qualifying finish sets were audited. This is not a claim of zero MVP votes; lower-ranked ballots were not exhaustively collected.
Cutoff status evidence: Source 1
Verified retired before cutoff and below ordinary 100-start threshold.
The complete qualifying finish sets were audited. This is not a claim of zero MVP votes; lower-ranked ballots were not exhaustively collected.
Cutoff status evidence: Source 1
At least 100 regular-season starts; retirement status cannot change eligibility.
The complete qualifying finish sets were audited. This is not a claim of zero MVP votes; lower-ranked ballots were not exhaustively collected.
ap All Pro Seasons: 2019
super Bowl Starts: 2013; 2014
super Bowl Winning Starts: 2013
conference Championship Starts: 2013 · Source 1; 2014 · Source 1
Cutoff status evidence: Source 1
Verified retired before cutoff and below ordinary 100-start threshold.
The complete qualifying finish sets were audited. This is not a claim of zero MVP votes; lower-ranked ballots were not exhaustively collected.
super Bowl Starts: 2017
super Bowl Winning Starts: 2017
super Bowl Mvp Awards: 2017
conference Championship Starts: 2017 · Source 1
Cutoff status evidence: Source 1
At least 100 regular-season starts; retirement status cannot change eligibility.
The complete qualifying finish sets were audited. This is not a claim of zero MVP votes; lower-ranked ballots were not exhaustively collected.
Cutoff status evidence: Source 1
Verified retired before cutoff and below ordinary 100-start threshold.
The complete qualifying finish sets were audited. This is not a claim of zero MVP votes; lower-ranked ballots were not exhaustively collected.
Cutoff status evidence: Source 1
Verified retired before cutoff and below ordinary 100-start threshold.
The complete qualifying finish sets were audited. This is not a claim of zero MVP votes; lower-ranked ballots were not exhaustively collected.
Cutoff status evidence: Source 1
Verified retired before cutoff and below ordinary 100-start threshold.
The complete qualifying finish sets were audited. This is not a claim of zero MVP votes; lower-ranked ballots were not exhaustively collected.
Cutoff status evidence: Source 1
Fourteen seasons of AP quarterback All-Pro selections and qualifying MVP top-five finish sets; all 28 conference championships (56 starting quarterbacks); and all 14 Super Bowls from the 2012–2025 seasons. Starter identities were reconstructed from official game recaps and NFL summaries. Roster rings do not count as starts.
This completes the 2012 class audit. It does not certify outcome classifications for every year in the broader draft/signing archive, and it is not a predictive hit rate. Read the tier definitions.
Live pages can change; this ledger preserves scope and the stated cutoff.
NFL regular-season GS; total 42; latest listed season 2020
Reviewed 2026-11-16
NFL regular-season GS; total 151; latest listed season 2023
Reviewed 2026-11-16
NFL regular-season GS; total 25; latest listed season 2018
Reviewed 2026-11-16
NFL regular-season GS; total 30; latest listed season 2018
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Retirement after seven seasons; Manning, not Osweiler, led 2015 postseason starts
Published 2019-10-16 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
199 regular-season starts through 2024; two Super Bowl appearances; XLVIII win
Published 2025-03-27 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
200th, 201st, 202nd career starts occurred in first three weeks of 2025; this alone does not establish full-season total
Published 2025-09-24 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
2019 AP Second-Team All-Pro; first AP All-Pro selection
Published 2020-01-03 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
2013/2014 Super Bowls; XLVIII victory; one AP All-Pro season through Seattle tenure
Published 2022-03-16 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
58 regular-season starts; retirement
Published 2024-08-08 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
2017-season Super Bowl LII winning starter and MVP; 2024 retirement
Published 2024-08-08 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
GS rows 2012-2025 sum to 167; exclude every 2026 row and career TOTAL
Reviewed 2026-11-16
NFL regular-season GS; total 6; latest listed season 2015
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Empty GS table; blank must not be converted into verified zero
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Finished 2012 on practice squad
Published 2013-01-14 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
Released before 2013 regular season
Published 2013-09-02 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
Team retrospect states he never played an NFL regular-season game
Reviewed 2026-11-16
No NFL regular-season rows as of retrieval; supports team retrospective
Reviewed 2026-11-16
2012 complete drafted QB list and picks; Keenum explicitly undrafted
Reviewed 2026-11-16
2025 participation with passing statistics: Weeks 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 10
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Dart first start; Wilson explicitly backup
Published 2025-09-28 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
Dart started; Wilson entered for two plays in third quarter
Published 2025-10-10 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
Wilson replaced Dart at start of fourth quarter
Published 2025-11-09 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
Complete AP quarterback first/second-team selections; selection, not any vote.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Complete AP quarterback first/second-team selections; selection, not any vote.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Complete AP quarterback first/second-team selections; selection, not any vote.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Complete AP quarterback first/second-team selections; selection, not any vote.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Complete AP quarterback first/second-team selections; selection, not any vote.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Complete AP quarterback first/second-team selections; selection, not any vote.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Complete AP quarterback first/second-team selections; selection, not any vote.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Complete AP quarterback first/second-team selections; selection, not any vote.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Complete AP quarterback first/second-team selections; selection, not any vote.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Complete AP quarterback first/second-team selections; selection, not any vote.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Complete AP quarterback first/second-team selections; selection, not any vote.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Complete AP quarterback first/second-team selections; selection, not any vote.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Complete AP quarterback first/second-team selections; selection, not any vote.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Complete AP quarterback first/second-team selections; selection, not any vote.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
AP MVP qualifying top-five finish coverage, including ties; not a claim about all lower-ranked votes.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Both quarterbacks in contemporaneous NFL conference championship game recap.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Official NFL: Super Bowl summaries PDF pages 715–718; Super Bowl MVP list PDF page 512 / printed page 511. Seasons 2012–2024 only.
Published 2025-06-26 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
2025-season Super Bowl LX: Darnold/Maye quarterbacks; Seattle wins.
Published 2026-02-08 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
2025-season Super Bowl LX MVP Kenneth Walker III.
Published 2026-02-08 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
Affirmative club statement: entire 2012 rookie season on practice squad.
Published 2013-05-13 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
Official retired-player registry lists B.J. Coleman NFL career 2012–2012; combined with full-year practice squad and pre-2013 release. Current registry is not a dated retirement announcement.
Reviewed 2026-11-16
Firsthand Harnish interview; explicitly describes his decision to quit after Arizona/Seattle opportunity in 2015. Primary player testimony, not a secondary inference.
Published 2017-05-05 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
Official employer biography explicitly dates end of playing career to Ottawa in 2017.
Published 2024-01-10 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
Original DA Show interview report, published 2020; identifies NFL career end in 2018.
Published 2020-11-09 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
Original firsthand author interview: 2012 practice squad, release following 2013 camp, then Arena/CFL; left football in 2016.
Published 2025-08-23 · Reviewed 2026-11-16
Original November 2025 player interview: says chapter closed and no longer preparing to return; distinguish self-report from formal retirement filing.
Published 2025-11-13 · Reviewed 2026-11-16