FIND ME MY QB

Put the perspectives side by side

Same quarterback. Different questions and dates.

Read Mike’s value label next to the site’s existing sourced scouting notes. This page reorganizes those published notes; it adds no new analyst claims.

These reports do not share one date, scale or purpose. A mock selection is not a scouting grade. Differences may reflect timing, game context or wording; they do not establish analyst agreement or disagreement.

Drew MestemakerCJ CarrArch ManningLaNorris SellersDarian Mensah

Drew Mestemaker

Mike’s personal view

Rank 1 · Tier 1 · Top 10

November 14, 2026 · 11:36 a.m. Eastern

Mike’s stated top-10 preference. This is not a forecast of where the player will be selected.

Read the full original opinion

Dane Brugler · dated recap

Brugler liked his size, athletic ability and ability to vary throw velocity, while emphasizing the value of additional experience.

· Interview-host recap · A to Z Sports. Read the source →

November 12, 2026 board update: The Chargers’ official recap reports Drew Mestemaker at No. 2 overall on Brugler’s updated top 50. That is an all-position ranking, not a predicted draft selection or a declaration that he will enter the draft.

· Secondary reporting · Omar Navarro, Los Angeles Chargers. Read the official team recap → The Athletic’s full report was not accessible for independent verification here.

Other published perspective

Bill Sparks

Sparks highlights arm strength, pocket confidence and willingness to attack the middle of the field. Processing speed and translation to NFL concepts remain evaluation questions.

· Original analysis · Updated Big Board 1.0. Read Bill Sparks’s original analysis →

Your research question: Are these observations about the same period and aspect of play? What evidence would help you evaluate each one?

CJ Carr

Mike’s personal view

Rank 2 · Tier 1 · Top 10

November 14, 2026 · 11:36 a.m. Eastern

Mike’s stated top-10 preference. This is not a forecast of where the player will be selected.

Read the full original opinion

Dane Brugler · dated recap

Brugler viewed his tools as sufficient, with development and operating the offense still central to the evaluation.

· Interview-host recap · A to Z Sports. Read the source →

Other published perspective

Dylan Feltovich

Feltovich describes an efficient distributor who could fit Frank Reich’s offense. He projects Carr to the Jets at No. 16, but says Carr would not be his first Quarterback choice. This is a team-specific mock selection, not a prospect grade.

· Original analysis · Jets post-trade-deadline mock. Read Dylan Feltovich’s original analysis →

Your research question: Are these observations about the same period and aspect of play? What evidence would help you evaluate each one?

Arch Manning

Mike’s personal view

Rank 3 · Tier 2 · Late 1st / early 2nd *

November 14, 2026 · 11:36 a.m. Eastern

* A player-value label. Mike would not spend those later premium picks on someone he is not fully sold on.

Read the full original opinion

Dane Brugler · dated recap

Brugler described an uneven first half of the season relative to preseason development expectations.

· Interview-host recap · A to Z Sports. Read the source →

Other published perspective

Bill Sparks

After the Missouri game, Sparks saw more decisive play, improved comfort and aggression under pressure across the field. He cautioned that one strong performance did not erase earlier inconsistency.

· Original analysis · Week 10 game observation. Read Bill Sparks’s original analysis →

Your research question: Are these observations about the same period and aspect of play? What evidence would help you evaluate each one?

LaNorris Sellers

Mike’s personal view

Rank 4 · Tier 2 · Late 1st / early 2nd *

November 14, 2026 · 11:36 a.m. Eastern

* A player-value label. Mike would not spend those later premium picks on someone he is not fully sold on.

Read the full original opinion

Dane Brugler · dated recap

Brugler highlighted the unusual combination of size, speed and power. This is a scouting observation, not a verified timed workout.

· Secondary quotation recap · Yardbarker. Read the source →

Other published perspective

Bill Sparks

Sparks praises explosive passing and running against Oklahoma and longer stretches of high-level play. Interceptions, including a pick-six in that game, remain a concern.

· Original analysis · Week 9 game observation. Read Bill Sparks’s original analysis →

Your research question: Are these observations about the same period and aspect of play? What evidence would help you evaluate each one?

Darian Mensah

Mike’s personal view

Rank 5 · Tier 2 · Late 1st / early 2nd *

November 14, 2026 · 11:36 a.m. Eastern

* A player-value label. Mike would not spend those later premium picks on someone he is not fully sold on.

Read the full original opinion

Dane Brugler · dated recap

Brugler praised accuracy, touch and decisions, while questioning arm explosiveness, reactions inside the pocket and ultimate ceiling.

· Interview-host recap · A to Z Sports. Read the source →

Other published perspective

Bill Sparks

Sparks praises accuracy, controlled distribution and care with the football. At that point, he wanted stronger defensive tests to assess pressure responses and difficult-window throws. This assessment predates the November Notre Dame game.

· Original analysis · Historical October assessment. Read Bill Sparks’s original analysis →

Your research question: Are these observations about the same period and aspect of play? What evidence would help you evaluate each one?